A federal judge threw out Sarah Palin's defamation lawsuit against the New York Times on Tuesday in a decision praised by journalists and free press advocates.
The former vice presidential candidate had sued the paper over a recent editorial tying one of her campaign group's ads to an Arizona shooting in 2011 that killed six and severely injured then-congresswoman Gabby Giffords.
SEE ALSO:As disaster unfolds in Houston, local media meet the challengeBut the judge said the Times' prompt correction and apology helped make clear the mistake wasn't made maliciously, a legal prerequisite for most defamation cases against public figures.
"Nowhere is political journalism so free, so robust, or perhaps so rowdy as in the United States," Judge Jed Rakoff wrote in his opinion. "In the exercise of that freedom, mistakes will be made, some of which will be hurtful to others."
Tweet may have been deleted
Tweet may have been deleted
The New York Timeswas happy with the outcome.
"Judge Rakoff's opinion is an important reminder of the country's deep commitment to a free press and the important role that journalism plays in our democracy," a spokesperson said in a statement. "We regret the errors we made in the editorial. But we were pleased to see that the court acknowledged the importance of the prompt correction we made once we learned of the mistakes."
Many experts agreed beforehand that Palin's legal crusade had little chance of clearing the country's comparatively high bar for press complaints from people considered newsworthy.
But at a time when judges have signaled a seeming willingness to rethink America's strict press freedom protections, a president has vowed to tighten libel laws, and media lawsuits from strong-arming billionaires are piling up, nothing can be taken for granted.
Tweet may have been deleted
Tweet may have been deleted
The Timeseditorial in question was published in the wake of a politically motivated shooting at a Virginia baseball field this June that left Lousiana Rep. Steve Scalise in critical condition.
In an attempt to draw a parallel with the Giffords shooting, the paper's editorial board suggested that an ad from Palin's political action committee motivated Giffords' would-be assassin. The ad featured a map with rifle-scope crosshairs superimposed on vulnerable electoral districts, though not on any image of Giffords herself as the Timesincorrectly implied.
That theory was widely debunked at the time, and the editorial caught deserved flak from across the political spectrum. The offending sentences were quickly removed with an appended correction, and the Timesapologized to its readers but neglected to contact Palin directly, according to the court proceedings.
Tweet may have been deleted
Palin said the fix wasn't enough. She sued later that month, alleging that the paper's editors knew what they said was wrong and published it anyway.
Palin's office didn't immediately respond to a request for comment.
(责任编辑：時尚)
Old lady swatting at a cat ends up in Photoshop battle
Election Day memes lighten the mood. And they talk about Katy Perry, too.'Dead to Me' deeply moving series finale connects 5 things to the pilotFBI director shares TikTok data privacy concernsOld lady swatting at a cat ends up in Photoshop battleAustralian football makes history with first LGBT Pride Game
The rainbow flag took over Melbourne's Etihad Stadium Saturday night in a powerful statement of acce
...[详细]Donald Trump has an aide who follows him on the golf course to show him positive articles
Former President Donald Trump is as addicted to Being Online as the rest of us. But he also happens
...[详细]'Dead to Me' deeply moving series finale connects 5 things to the pilot
Well, as Jen would say, fuck.If you've just finished Beachesthe series finale of Dead to Me, bring i
...[详细]Election Day memes lighten the mood. And they talk about Katy Perry, too.
Election Day in the U.S. is an important day, for sure, but it's also a great day for memes and joke
...[详细]Here's George Takei chilling in zero gravity for the 'Star Trek' anniversary
There's nothing like good friends, good memories and zero gravity to celebrate a milestone.。In honor
...[详细]Apple Music Replay reminds you which songs you binged the most in 2022
Apple Music Replay is back, and this time it's designed to be viewed on your phone. Once again, it's
...[详细]Elon Musk suspends Kanye West's Twitter account
Ye's account on Twitter has been suspended. The news was shared by Twitter CEO Elon Musk, who said t
...[详细]Instafest app: How to get your personalised Spotify music festival lineup
It's almost the end of the year, which means it's almost time for everyone to share their Spotify li
...[详细]Pole vaulter claims his penis is not to blame
Following the cringeworthy moment in which pole vaulter Hiroki Ogita's penis grazed the bar and he f
...[详细]Instafest app: How to get your personalised Spotify music festival lineup
It's almost the end of the year, which means it's almost time for everyone to share their Spotify li
...[详细]This coloring book is here for all your relationship goals
Spotify Wrapped's mood descriptions are confusing the internet