The National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) filed a complaint against SpaceX on Wednesday, accusing it of unfair labour practices and unlawful dismissal. Now, SpaceX has responded — by filing a lawsuit claiming that NLRB's entire structure violates the Constitution.
The Elon Musk-owned company sued the NLRB in a Texas federal court on Thursday, arguing that the government agency is unconstitutional because the U.S. President does not have a "constitutionally required degree of control" over its administrative law judges (ALJs).
SEE ALSO:SpaceX charged with unlawfully firing employees critical of Elon MuskSpecifically, SpaceX claims that the President should be able to remove the NLRB's judges without cause because the Constitution requires that the President use executive power to "take Care that the Laws be faithfully executed." In SpaceX's apparent view, this responsibility should include more complete control over who is executing said laws.
"[T]he ALJs are removable only for cause, by officials who themselves are removable only for cause," read SpaceX's complaint.
SpaceX also argues that the NLRB violates the separation of powers by serving simultaneously as prosecutor and adjudicator, exercising legislative, executive, and judicial powers in its administrative proceedings. Further, the company claims that adjudication by the NLRB's administrative law judges violates its Seventh Amendment right to a trial by jury.
"Even after acting as prosecutor by charging SpaceX with violations of federal labor law before an Article III tribunal, the same NLRB Members would then issue the agency's ultimate order on whether SpaceX has violated federal labor law," the complaint read.
SEE ALSO:Lawsuit against major social media companies moves forwardIf the unlawful dismissal case against SpaceX goes ahead, it would first be heard by a NLRB administrative judge, then a five-member board appointed by the President. This decision wouldn't necessarily be final though, with the respondent still able to appeal in federal court.
Even so, SpaceX is clearly disinterested in letting it get that far. The company has requested that the court stop the NLRB from proceeding with the charges, as well as declare NLRB's structure unconstitutional and permanently prevent it from bringing unfair labour practice charges against SpaceX until this is rectified.
Mashable has reached out to SpaceX for comment. The NLRB declined to comment.
Notably, SpaceX did not provide any further response to NLRB's specific allegations that the company violated the National Labor Relations Act. SpaceX has been accused of unlawfully firing employees who criticised CEO Musk, as well as interrogating, intimidating, coercing, and implicitly threatening others.
One would think that directly addressing such allegations would be easier than attempting to undermine an 88-year-old government agency. However, considering that the NLRB didn't find SpaceX's defence compelling enough to dissuade it from filing charges, the company may not have much faith in its ability to win with more conventional arguments.
TopicsSpaceXPolitics
(责任编辑：百科)
Give your kitchen sponge a rest on this adorable bed
8 joyful examples of how Australian TV got even more bizarre in 20168 joyful examples of how Australian TV got even more bizarre in 2016Veteran soldier becomes the face of demonetization woes in IndiaThis coloring book is here for all your relationship goalsWhat brands need to know about virtual reality
Virtual reality (VR) is all the rage. Premium publishers like USA Today, the New York Times, and AOL
...[详细]This airline sacrificed a goat on the tarmac before its flight took off
Pakistan International Airlines may have resumed flying operations for its ATR planes, but mere clea
...[详细]2016: The year Facebook became the bad guy
Facebook numbs us. It's supposed to: As an app and social network, it offers an unending feed of com
...[详细]Tech can help us spot fake news, but there's only one real way to stop it
In the days after the election, apoplectic progressive journalists spent their time writing boiling
...[详细]Snapchat is about to explode in popularity, report says
Snapchat is about to have a couple of really good years.。The company will see huge gains in the numb
...[详细]Toddler's misunderstanding inspires the perfect New Year's family tradition
Toddlers say the dardest things, are we right CBS?Reddit user littlasskicker uploaded a picture of t
...[详细]'Harry Potter' casting director explains why Robin Williams couldn't play Hagrid
When the。 Harry Potter 。movies began casting exclusively for British talent, there were no exceptions
...[详细]This airline sacrificed a goat on the tarmac before its flight took off
Pakistan International Airlines may have resumed flying operations for its ATR planes, but mere clea
...[详细]U.S. pole vaulter skids to a halt for national anthem
An American pole vaulter took his patriotism to the next level at the Olympics.
。Sam Kendricks, a sec
...[详细]Woman gets horny guy to kiss a tractor for a chance at nude pictures
Oh, the embarrassing lengths some people will go for a naked picture.Twitter user @ktyshrmn shared a
...[详细]Tributes flow after death of former Singapore president S.R. Nathan
World map proves basically every country has a terrible tourism slogan